祁建平律师网

qijianping.fabao365.com

获取律师电话请拨打

15811286610

我的位置:首页 > 时事新闻 > 正文

Stevens hears last argument as

2010-05-02 11:38:16 来源:


Stevens hears last argument as

Stevens hears last argument as justice

By JESSE J. HOLLAND Associated Press Writer

WASHINGTON (AP) - It was a classic John Paul Stevens tactic: wait until the closing seconds and then ask a lawyer a pointed question.

The 90-year-old justice employed it for the last time Wednesday as he sat through the final high court arguments of his 35-year career.

Stevens has announced his retirement this summer. He will continue to appear with the court through June, issuing and writing opinions on cases that were argued last year and earlier this year.

But Wednesday's arguments - over whether the name of petition signers who wanted to overturn Washington state's domestic partnership law should be made public - was his last chance to interact with lawyers appearing before the court.

Known as a gentle but pointed interrogator, the bespectacled Stevens has heard more than 3,500 arguments from lawyers in the Supreme Court's courtroom. So as is his custom, Stevens - wearing his usual bow tie - rocked back and forth in his chair for most of the arguments.

He watched silently as lawyer James Bopp Jr. argued that the state's position was that the names should be disclosed so the public can ensure that there is no fraud. But as Bopp was preparing to wrap up, Stevens cleared his throat and leaned forward.

"Isn't there another possible public interest? Would it be legitimate public interest to say, 'I would like to know who signed the petition, because I would like to try to persuade them that their views should be modified?' Is there public interest in encouraging debate on the underlying issue?" Stevens said.

"Well, it's possible, but we think this information is marginal," Bopp said.

Signing a referendum petition does identify people who have certain point of view, Stevens replied. "And if you have the other point of view, don't you have an interest in finding out who you would like to convince to change their minds?" he said.

President Barack Obama has said he hopes to have Stevens' replacement confirmed before the court's new term begins in October.

2010-04-28     22:09:04 GMT

大家都在看
时评律师
更多>

安庆小伙高温加班12小时死事件分析

时评律师:李先奇

擅长领域:合同纠纷  劳动纠纷  债权债务  公司并购  股份转让  企业改制  刑事辩护  外商投资  常年顾问  私人律师

雷政富重庆受审:借款行为是否构成受贿?

时评律师:高文龙

擅长领域:刑事辩护

从刘志军案看职务犯罪的预防

时评律师:李先奇

擅长领域:合同纠纷  劳动纠纷  债权债务  公司并购  股份转让  企业改制  刑事辩护  外商投资  常年顾问  私人律师

阴阳购房合同效力如何认定

时评律师:李顺涛

擅长领域:医疗事故  交通事故  婚姻家庭  遗产继承  劳动纠纷  合同纠纷  罪与非罪  债权债务  房产纠纷

厦门brt爆炸案赔偿方案分析

时评律师:李先奇

擅长领域:合同纠纷  劳动纠纷  债权债务  公司并购  股份转让  企业改制  刑事辩护  外商投资  常年顾问  私人律师